Saturday, November 18, 2017

Songwriters Needed

America has a heritage of great songwriters.
Long before Dolly Parton, Willie Nelson, Prince, and Bruce Springsteen were winning awards, George and Ira Gershwin, Dorothy Fields, Irving Berlin, Cole Porter, and others were producing pieces still sung today, especially by vintage rockers.  These artists wrote about romance, heartbreak, patriotism, and life.  But so far as I can tell none of those featured in the Great American Songbook collection wrote about Thanksgiving.  Oh, others have written a few novelty songs about the holiday but none from the likes of Irving Berlin—who, by the way, showed his versatility with songs about a White Christmas and an Easter Parade. For some reason, we just don’t have many songs about the fourth Thursday in November.
This explains why I was listening to Holly Jolly Christmas on Veterans’ Day.
In fairness, there is Adam Sandler’s Thanksgiving Song but, after reading the lyrics, I think I’d rather listen to “Little Drummer Boy” a dozen times in one day. In 1832, Samuel Smith mentioned “pilgrim’s pride” in My Country ‘tis of Thee but he makes no reference to the holiday they gave us (yes, it was years before Lincoln proclaimed the holiday).  Today, the term is used for a famous brand of turkey--even though the pilgrims would be dismayed at being remembered for their pride.
You won’t find references to turkeys, cranberries, or pumpkin pies but you can find songs of thanksgiving in the hymnal.
In them we are called to give thanks for God’s blessings in general and, in particular, for his creation, his grace, his faithfulness, his goodness, his salvation.
This Thursday, when our families get together, when we watch football games with all those commercials to remind us Christmas is coming, when we regret eating too much, and when we end the day by hugging goodbye to those won’t be seeing for a while, we should remember something about the giving thanks.  What we should remember is well expressed in Leonard Burks simple hymn:
Everyday is a day of thanksgiving.
God's been so good to me,
   everyday He's blessing me.
             Everyday is a day of thanksgiving;
               take the time to glorify the Lord today.





Thursday, November 9, 2017

Celebrity

Years ago in a small Texas town, members of the high school football team, fresh from practice, pumped about what might be a championship season, and eager for a bit of fun, broke into a mom-and-pop hamburger joint.  They threw frozen burgers and fries at each other, littering the parking lot with food worth hundreds of dollars.  They opened pop cans, drank a few gulps and tossed them aside.  Thrown to the evening wind, paper napkins resembled drunken doves flitting across the Panhandle sky. Further damage was forestalled when the local police arrived.  Small town law takes exception to trespass and vandalism.  Usually.
No criminal charges were brought. No stories in the local newspaper shamed the miscreants.  No one was suspended from school.  No one was booted off the team.
Parents and supporters quietly paid the damages and the Friday-night lights shined as brightly as ever.
“Celebrity”—even with a small “c”—carries a lot of weight.
During last year’s presidential campaign, a 2005 recording of Donald Trump surfaced.  The so-called “locker-room tape” featured the future president boasting of the kinds of things a man could get away with if he was rich and famous.
Though not multimillionaire TV moguls, those football players discovered what Trump had discovered.  If you’re famous—even small town famous—you can get away with things.  The president of the chess club might be stripped of her position and given community service but not the star quarterback.
If the tape hurt Trump, it didn’t hurt him enough to keep him out of The White House.  Many people refused to vote for him after hearing the tape; others gritted their teeth and voted for him; others weren’t bothered at all by his statements.  Imagine what his margin of victory might have been had we never heard the tapes and the things he talked about.  Crude and reprehensible things.
The kind of things we are learning rich and famous men, both straight and homosexual, have apparently been getting away with for decades.
Nearly a year later, we are again hearing about acts rich and famous men have committed with impunity.  Harvey Weinstein, Ben Affleck, and Kevin Spacey are those being talked about today.  Tomorrow we will almost certainly hear of others who abused their celebrity to force their attention on young women or young men—dreamers trying to make it big in a city where “all the stars that never were are parking cars and pumping gas.”  Who could blame these young people for convincing themselves that if they want the fame and the name, the touch of unwelcome hands is the cost of doing business?  Who would be surprised if these same people, a few years later, concluded they had been exploited and abused? 
Those who have never toured Hollywood or stood by a favorite performer’s star on the walk of fame have heard of “the casting couch.” We may have been told the stories were myth but often those denying the stories did so with a wink and a nudge.
But, now it seems a few women—and some men—have said enough is enough.  No more.  Big screen legends are saying, “No other ingénue should go through what I went through.”  Collectively, Hollywood seems to be saying, “No more.”
That being said, how far will this indignation go?  Will the reverberations change things in the business world, the sports world, the political world?
Ben Zimmer, writing in a recent issue of The Atlantic, explains the term “casting couch” originated with the Shubert brothers of Broadway fame and then migrated across the country to America’s burgeoning film-capital, Hollywood.  There the couch became a fixture in producers’ offices, directors’ offices, agents’ offices and wherever else men dictated the future of aspiring actors and actresses. 
Now, here are questions worth pondering while you mute the political screeds during the next Tony Awards: Should the Tony Awards apologize for using the Shubert Theatre so often as a venue? While we are still taking down the statues of Confederate generals, should we send a crew over to take down the marquee of that historic venue?  Since Radio City Music Hall, the most recent venue for the awards show, is sometimes vilified by feminists (the Rockettes, you know) maybe the next Tony Awards be held at Columbus’s Value City Arena—a little humility couldn’t hurt some of those folk?
Do not misunderstand.  Sexual harassment is not a joking matter.  But just as those high-school football players (who were “famous” for a brief time in a small town) got away with destroying so much food, rich and famous men may continue to get away with harassing powerless women.  Unless there are real and substantial changes.
Sexual harassment has been with us a long time.  Remember, the Biblical story of Joseph.  Sold by his brothers into slavery, Joseph found himself a servant in the household of an Egyptian official named Potiphar.  Joseph was did good work but was cursed—with good looks.  Potiphar’s wife noticed.  She propositioned Joseph. He refused.  As happens today, she didn’t stop. Again and again she propositioned the young man; again and again he refused.  Finally, angered at being rebuffed, she cried, “Rape.”  Joseph was unceremoniously thrown into prison. That he didn’t face execution has prompted some to suggest Potiphar knew the kind of women his wife was.  Interestingly, one mantra frequently heard after the Weinstein story broke was “we all knew.”
Except in rare cases, those who sexually harass women (or men) today cannot send those who refuse their advances to jail; they can, however, make life tougher.  Harvey Weinstein could end a hopeful actress’s career before it started; a department head at a local business can make sure a woman never is considered for promotion.
Because we live in a broken world (I’m a theologian, I think in such terms), humans will continue to abuse, misuse, and otherwise exploit one another no matter how enlightened we claim to be.  Sexual harassment, like racism, will continue to be part of the human experience until the Eschaton (theologian!?). But this doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try to do something about it.
It does mean it won’t be easy. 
In The Place Accorded of Old (available as an e-book from Amazon), I suggest the hostility between men and women is rooted in the Fall.  Though we sometimes joke about this hostility, it has serious expressions, including sexism and abuse.  Genesis 3:16 underscored this reality when God says to Eve, “Your desire shall be for (or against) your husband, and he shall rule over you.”  Some translations indicated the word “desire,” implies “a desire to control.” (Expanded Bible, translators’ note)  As one conservative commentary explains:
 The word desire (Heb. teshûgâ) can also mean “an attempt to usurp or control” as in 4:7.   We can paraphrase the last two lines of this verse this way: “You will now have a tendency to dominate your husband, and he will have the tendency to act as a tyrant over you.” The battle of the sexes has begun. Each strives for control and neither lives in the best interest of the other (Phil. 2:3, 4). The antidote is in the restoration of mutual respect and dignity through Jesus Christ (Eph. 5:21–33).[1]
While commentators (like the one cited) tend to limit their application to marriage, there are broader implications.  The abusers cannot really respect the young women they grope and coerce into sex.  There is doubtless much truth in the observation: “Rape is not so much about sexual pleasure as it is about control and power.”  We can imagine men like those we’ve been hearing about keeping mental diaries of their experiences to review whenever a victim gets a good review or wins an award.
Ideally, if the arrogant disrespect demonstrated in men sexually assaulting vulnerable young women is a manifestation of the Fall, we Christians should expect the redemptive work of Christ in reversing that Fall to establish a new relationship between men and women. But such is the power of sin that this has not yet happened.  Even professed Christians have sometimes conspired to limit the women’s freedom, though I know of none who believe women to be legitimate targets of sexual aggression. Still, we should allow the vision of a better way to shape our laws and practices. 
Producers, directors, CEOs, athletes, and other celebrities seem to feel entitled to treat women however they may wish. Doubtless, these same men would react with shock when reading journalists like Mohammed Hanif who told about “pious men” who defend “a man’s God-given right to give a woman a little thrashing,” who make “it impossible for women to prove rape,” and “defended a man’s right to marry a minor.” Or would they? 
In 2009, when admitted child-molester Roman Polanski was detained in Zurich (at the request of US authorities hoping he might be extradited), there was a protest among the elite of the entertainment world.  Long after he had admitted to unlawful sexual contact with a thirteen-year-old girl and subsequently skipped bail to avoid sentencing, the filmmaker continued to win awards.  In fact, Polanski was in Switzerland to receive a lifetime achievement award.  The complaints against Polanski came from some of Hollywood’s loudest voices.  Harvey Weinstein attempted to rally the troops in Polanski’s defense: “We're calling on every film-maker we can to help fix this terrible situation."  (“Outcry Over Polanski’s Detention,” BBC News, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8277886.stm.  Accessed 5 November 2017) Wait, Harvey who?  Ironic, huh?
Every week new charges are being brought against the rich, famous, and powerful in Hollywood and elsewhere.  Female legislators in state capitals are reporting being harassed by male legislators.  Political ideology doesn’t seem to matter.  Both Fox News’s Bill O’Reilly and Michael Oreskes, head of NPR News, have been accused of harassment.
The problem is widespread and won’t go away quickly. 
Still, we need to create structures to protect the vulnerable.  Professional organizations should develop effective ways to police their own members.  Since “everyone knew” about Harvey Weinstein’s behavior, it certainly seems reasonable some actors’ unions or other organizations could have found ways to create a more protective environment for their members. 
We need to reevaluate our values.  Those high school football players got away with their vandalism because community leaders knew a winning team would bring honor to a town otherwise known only for the aroma of the local feed lot.  Harvey Weinstein’s behavior was tolerated because his movies made money. Established actors and actresses might refuse to work for a director or producer known to have a casting couch in the office.
Naïve?  Sure. 
But over the years I’ve met a lot of young people who have been bitten by the acting bug.  (It never happened to me though I have been bitten by bugs while watching them perform.) Most are content to explore the options available to them in central Ohio, content to keep their day jobs and do theatre in their spare time.  Still, I’d like to think if they should head off to Hollywood, New York, Toronto, or elsewhere to pursue greater glory, they will be safe from predators of all kinds.
I can’t protect them.  But actors and actresses with courage and integrity might help build a defense around such newcomers.  In fact, I suspect only established actors and actresses can find a way to protect newcomers from notorious predators.
Of course, I know far more young people preparing for careers in business, education, and other professions.  Wouldn’t it be great if corporate boards told CEOs down to the lowest level supervisors, “We don’t care how good you are or how much money you make, cross this line and you’re out.”  Maybe coaches should tell players they will be off the team if they beat-up a girlfriend or wife.  Maybe the same Americans who are tired of watching NFL games where the flag is disrespected should refuse to watch teams allowing wife/girlfriend abusers to take the field.
Just saying.

So far as I know, those young players went on from high school to the ordinary.  I don’t know if they boast of their costly food-fight or pray their children never learn of it.
Donald Trump’s boast of what a man like him could do without fear of retribution threatened his presidential bid a decade later.  (Some might say it didn’t threaten it enough.)  His words merited the outrage they engendered.  But, looking back, I wonder if some were outraged not because of what he said but because he said it.  He let the world in on a little secret—a secret we all knew—about the rich and the famous: they all too often get away with things.   It will be difficult to change or penalize their behavior in a meaningful way.  A poor woman who loses her license for DUI walks or takes the bus, a rich woman hires a chauffeur.  Still we need to try to find a way to challenge and change things.
For what happened to the young actresses we are hearing about was not just about sex, it was about the presumptions made by the rich and the powerful.






[1]Radmacher, Earl D.; Allen, Ronald Barclay; House, H. Wayne: Nelson's New Illustrated Bible Commentary. Nashville : T. Nelson Publishers, 1999, S. Ge 3:16

Sunday, October 29, 2017

On Jack-o’-Lanterns and Christmas Trees



My church in Texas tried something different one Halloween.  Rather than having each parent drive the country roads around the village of Dawn as their costumed kids pursued their trick-or-treat mission, the church would take all the kids in its big van.  We announced the plan in Sunday school.  Both parents and kids seemed to like the idea.  Dads wouldn’t have to leave the fields early and moms could make sure dinner was ready when dad came in.  The kids liked the idea of being out after dark with their friends.  Since the homes they would visit were miles apart, they would have plenty of time to scrutinize their candy haul and maybe trade something they didn’t like for something they did.
The Sunday before Halloween we asked parents to sign permission forms allowing us to take their children.  Mid-afternoon Halloween I realized we didn’t have the forms for “the Alexander” children, two girls and a boy.   I took a set over to the Alexander place.  I walked past several carved pumpkins and knocked on the door—festooned as it was with cobwebs, black crepe paper runners, and construction-paper bats.  Mrs. Alexander opened the door; she was dressed as a witch.  I hope I stifled my surprise but I’m not sure I managed.  Spooky music played as she signed the papers.  This family was into Halloween.
Now, let’s jump forward about five weeks. It’s nearing Christmas.  Most Thursday evenings I led a program called Kids for Christ; we studied a Bible story, had refreshments, and did a simple craft project.  This evening we were making Christmas tree ornaments.  I noticed the Alexander boy seemed unenthused about his ornament.  I asked if something was wrong.  “We don’t have a Christmas tree,” he said.  “Ah, well,” I said, “you probably just don’t have it yet.  You can use your ornament when your parents put up the tree.”  “No,” his younger sister said, “we never have a tree.”  “Our parents don’t believe in Christmas trees,” the oldest sister said solemnly.
The next day, I called the home to tell Mrs. Alexander I hoped they hadn’t been offended by my having their kids make ornaments.  “No, we weren’t offended,” she said, “We’ll just hang the ornaments somewhere else.”  Prompted by curiosity, I said, “The children didn’t explain much about why you don’t have a tree.” She said bluntly, “The Bible says they’re wrong.” She then mentioned a verse in Isaiah she felt settled the case. 
Of course, I knew there were no Christmas trees in the eighth century before Christ, so Isaiah wasn’t writing about them.  Back at the office I read the verse.  It turns out the prophet was condemning the practice of hewing down trees to make idols.  I didn’t mention that to the Alexander’s—some arguments are not worth winning—and they kept coming to the church despite my Yuletide arboreal heresy.
It’s known “Christmas” trees were used in sixteenth-century Latvia; but they were likely used well before this.  (The claim Martin Luther—about whom we’ve heard so much lately—invented the Christmas tree is not reliable.) Families were using decorated evergreen trees in their homes for centuries before the birth of Christ to symbolize the hope of life surviving the bleak winter.  Under the leadership of missionaries to northern European tribes, the practice was “baptized” and used to remind people of the new life Christ brought the first Christmas.  Not every Christian leader approved but theirs was a losing battle.
But I digress.
After my conversation with Mrs. Alexander, I thought of how I knew several Christians who strenuously objected to Halloween with its witches, demons, and devils but thought nothing of having a Christmas tree in their home.  Now, here were Christian parents who relished Halloween—a holiday populated by the denizens of the night—and eschewed the Christmas tree because they thought it pagan.  Christians can be peculiar and I don’t mean in the First Peter 2:9 (KJV) sense.
When I was a kid, Halloween was a holiday for dressing up and getting lots of candy.  I remember having a skeleton costume I used for several years but I don’t remember dressing as anything else, though I’m sure I did.  As I recall, costumes based on TV characters seemed limited to Zorro or Superman—no one dressed like Matt Dillon, Perry Mason or Annie Oakley (she was an Ohioan, you know).  Product licensing was around but seemed limited to lunch boxes and a few toys.  Only later did Hollywood realize there might be money in My Little Pony shampoo or Walking Dead moisturizer.  I had given up trick-or-treating by 1962 when The Beverly Hillbillies began its climb to the top of the Nielsen ratings; still, I doubt anyone ever dressed up as Jethro Bowdin or certainly not Elly May Clampett (it was cold and, more important, no father would have allowed it). Someday historians will be able to create a year-to-year gauge of what was popular in our culture by examining the Halloween costumes sold.  I’m sure we will see Wonder Woman, Star Lord, Groot, and even Pennywise at our door this Tuesday. 
But I digress.
I attended Sunday school regularly, even won a couple lapel pins for my faithfulness.  On average, I sat with my parents in some church for at least fifty Sundays every year (we often attended church on vacation). Not once do I recall a lesson or a sermon on the evils of Halloween.  The Sunday school even sponsored Halloween parties—complete with costume contests and bobbing for apples. I never won since a skeleton at Halloween is hardly creative and never joined in the bobbing since I hate water in my nose.  Still, it was fun.  And it was a “Halloween Party,” not a “Fall Festival,” not a “Harvest Jamboree,” not a “Hallow-Him Party,” not even an “Eve-of-All-Saints Day” party. 
I was a young adult before I knew some churches and Christian leaders condemned Halloween as a day to honor Satan.  I don’t deny there are devil-worshippers in our culture but very few others would imagine they were honoring Satan on Halloween; no more than they would imagine they were honoring the Sun god on “Sunday.” But we Christians are a quirky lot so we have folks who get nervous about the holiday.
But our quirkiness doesn’t stop there.
If you’re married, look at your left hand.  Chances are you’re wearing a wedding ring.  We see them all around us.  But if the English Puritans had had their way, you might not be wearing a ring.  They believed wedding rings were a vestige of popery and the hated “Romanism.”  In fact, when the Scottish king James VI was on his way to London to receive the English crown as King James I, he was confronted by a band of petition-carrying Puritans who demanded, among other things, the removal of the ring ceremony from the Book of Common Prayer.  James, who hated to be bullied by religious types, refused.  To placate the Puritans, he eventually promised them a new translation of the Bible and we all know how that turned out.
But many Puritans were so disappointed at the king’s refusal to make the changes they demanded, they took off to the new world to create “a city on a hill,” a model Christian community which would be the envy of everyone back home.  In “new” England the Sabbath would be honored, clergy would dress in simple attire; and, I suppose, there would be no wedding rings. They imagined being invited back to do the same thing for “old” England. And we all know how that turned out.
Now, this raises a question:  Are you embarrassed or ashamed of what happened after those Puritans and other Europeans invaded North America?  Who isn’t?  You might want to stop wearing that wedding ring—a trigger for the invasion.  Take it off. Put it in a drawer. Never be seen wearing it again. And good luck explaining your noble rational to your spouse.
But I digress.
The problem isn’t our quirkiness; it’s how our idiosyncrasies blind us to what is really important.  If you don’t want to celebrate Halloween, that’s fine.  Just be sure you don’t end up honoring Satan by your judgmental attitude toward Christians with Jack-o’-lanterns on their porches.  When we major on minors that can happen.
I had an aunt who loudly let it be known she wouldn’t have a Monopoly game in her house.  Her reason? The game contains a pair of dice.  I can only assume she feared, if she allowed a Monopoly game in the house, one evening my cousins would be seized by an overwhelming urge to fall down on all fours and start a game of craps.  Seriously, her church condemned all forms of gambling and she didn’t want the gambler’s tools in her home.
I suppose she was taking a stand for her faith but I’m not sure how effective my aunt’s efforts were in raising pious children.  My cousin and a female friend once beat up a preacher for saying something they didn’t like.  Years later, my cousin remained unrepentant, even proud of that act of violence.  My cousin was one tough woman.  We’re left to wonder if my aunt might have done more to advance the faith by teaching her daughter self-control and forgiveness.
No Bible verse asked my aunt to give up playing any game—no matter how boring it might be.  A few decades into the second century some Christians began insisting new believers be baptized in cold water.  Baptisms on a sunny Mediterranean beach could never be spiritual.  Had he known, Paul would have just shaken his head…and maybe reached for his pen.