Friday, April 13, 2018

Gun Control: Old and New


Conversation about the relationship of church and state eventually turns to the Founders’ intentions in the First Amendment.  The same is true when we explore what those Founders envisioned when they framed the Second Amendment.  Samuel Adams (1722-1803) was one of the clearest voices on both issues.

Well before Adams signed the Declaration of Independence in 1776, he dreamed of Americans being free from Britain.  For that dream to become a reality, he knew the Americans would have to take charge of their destiny.  To do so they would have to be prepared.

Long before the revolution he urged Boston to pass laws requiring each citizen to own a firearm should an enemy threaten the community—though he left the enemy unnamed, Adams had the British in mind.  Then, as the US Constitution was being framed, Adams recommended the provision that became the Second Amendment. 

Of course, Adams never pictured the citizens grabbing their guns every time they might be unhappy with a government policy.  In a true republic, he thought, rebellion should be unnecessary since citizens have recourse to the ballot. This explains his harsh response to Shays’ Rebellion.  I wonder if Adams—an uncompromising advocate for a civilian-controlled military—would see any need for militia groups born out of paranoia directed at the federal government.  Consider his familiar statement on the right to own guns: “The Constitution shall never be construed... to prevent the people of the United States who are peaceable citizens from keeping their own arms.”  He defends the right to “own arms;” but that right pertains to “peaceable citizens.”  We might ask if he would describe militia groups as “peaceable.”

His words anticipate occasions when the right to keep arms might be revoked.  A felon, for instance, has failed to be a peaceable citizen, thus forfeiting the right to keep arms. The mentally-ill have the potential to act as other than peaceable and, for their sake and the community’s, may have their right to keep arms denied.  And, since the competence to live as a peaceable citizen requires a fundamental maturity, especially marked by a state of mind disinclined to act impulsively, Adams would likely suggest the right to keep arms be withheld until a certain age.


So, what would Adams think of today’s discussion about gun control?  Although he was not addressing the issue, we should recall his observation that we are usually “governed more by [our] feelings than by reason.”  Feelings are certainly on display whenever groups begin to discuss guns. 

While feelings may jump-start a movement, fear and outrage are usually not sufficient to yield long-term change, for individuals or for nations.  Intensity of emotion neither validates nor invalidates an argument.  Students at Florida’s Parkland High School are rightly passionate about changing gun laws after losing so many friends during the Valentine’s Day shooting.  Laura Ingraham’s snide comment’s about Parkland student David Hogg’s being rejected by four colleges no more invalidates his arguments than his having been accepted by Harvard, Yale, and Columbia on the same day would have validated them.  Hogg’s calling gun-rights advocates “sick f---kers” might be expected from an angry high school student though the language does not prove his case nor does it mean his case is meritless; just as Ingraham’s insensitivity, though she should have known better, does not disprove her “liberal” interpretation of the Second Amendment. 

My response to school shootings involves mixed emotions.  And, of course, the public debate is fraught with anger and fear, on both sides.  When feelings overrule reason we are tempted to push for quick, simple solutions.  Deal with shootings by banning guns.  Sounds great.  End the violence, simply and plainly.  But would we.  The UK has a stringent gun policy; yet in these early months of 2018 the murder count in London threatens to rival that of New York City.  While some of the deaths have involved guns, several have involved stabbing.  Knives capable of inflicting mortal wounds can be found in every kitchen in the UK and the US. 

I am writing while on a visit to Austin, Texas.  Citizens of Austin were terrorized recently by a serial bomber who built his bombs with materials from a DIY store.  While I wouldn’t know where to look, would-be bombers can find instructions on the Internet. 

So-called “vehicle ramming attacks” have occurred in many nations, including the US.  Drivers using cars and trucks have deliberately driven into crowds hoping to kill and maim as many as possible.  In October 2017 eight people died and several were injured when the driver of a rental truck jumped the curb in New York City and drove down a bicycle path.  In July 2016, the driver of a 20-ton truck plowed into a Bastille Day crowd in Nice, France, killing 84 and injuring more than 200.  In November of that year, an angry student drove his car into a crowd on the Ohio State University campus in Columbus; he jumped out to the car and began attacking people with a knife.  He wounded eight before he was shot by a campus police officer. 

No, you don’t need a gun if you set out to harm others.  Still, guns do the most harm.  They seem to be the go-to instruments for mayhem.  They are the most effective way to inflict damage—there is considerable wisdom in taking a gun to a knife fight.  And I doubt any robber has ever walked into a store, dangled his keys, and said, “Gimme your money, I’ve got a car.” (Apologies to George Strait.)

Perhaps even Sam Adams would see the need for reasonable gun control.  While Adams may have had no qualms about a neighbor—a “Squire Potter,” let’s say—owning a musket or two, we simply don’t know how he would feel about Squire Potter’s great-grandson owning a Gatling Gun or a late twentieth-century descendent owning an AK-47.   Though the pre-revolution Adams encouraged communities to own cannons and to maintain arsenals, would he have seen a need for his beloved Boston, or Worthington, Ohio; or Lafayette, Colorado, owning surface-to-air missiles after a civilian-controlled military assumed the task of defending the nation?

When we allow feeling to overrule reason in our defense of gun-rights, we may dig in our heels and refuse to see how much the world has changed, how criminal it would be to remain indifferent to the peril many of our neighbors face.  Shortly after moving to Ohio I heard a pastor say something I had never heard a pastor say in Texas. He urged his fellow pastors to support strict gun-control legislation.  A Southern Baptist and an African-American who served a church in a large urban area, he had conducted funerals for too many young victims of gun violence to support the policies many Baptist pastors would unthinkingly endorse.  His position reflected experiences I’d never had and likely would never have. I knew pastors in Texas who would have thought he had embraced a heresy comparable to Arianism.

Donations to the NRA’s “Political Victory Fund” were three times more in February than in January, about $779,000 to almost $250,000 (The Week, 13 April 2018, p. 16).  Was this burst of generosity merely coincidental or a panicked anticipation of calls for new firearm restrictions following the Parkland shooting?  One might assume the latter without being guilty of cynicism. 

Now, let’s be clear: The Bible does not address the issue of gun control.  We cannot point to any verse to tell us whether those who would have all guns banned or those who would insist we all own guns are right.

Still, in addressing gun control it’s likely Adams would keep one thought uppermost.  Adams, a staunch Christian of the Calvinist variety, took seriously the notion of depravity.  Whoever we may be, our behavior and our thinking may be off-center, at its best; corrupt, at its worst.  His belief in total depravity meant Adams would see the primary problem to be, not the guns people own but the people owning those guns.

Remember the painting by George Henry Boughton (1837-1905) depicting the Puritans walking to church on a snowy morning?  Boughton, sometimes called “the painter of New England Puritanism,” shows several families walking through a snowy wood to a little meetinghouse.  Men, women, and children are on their way to church; doubtless, looking forward to unimaginative singing, lengthy prayers, and a two-hour sermon. (Still, reality crept into the painting.)  Each man, except the minister, carries a musket; the men are armed to protect the band from marauding Indians. Though painted in 1867, the work nonetheless reminds us how the Puritans saw no contradiction between their faith and taking up arms to defend themselves. This was Adams’s heritage.  His spiritual and natural ancestry reached back to those men and women who founded New England.

Adams would know we Christians are obliged to be “in the world but not of the world.” We must live within our culture without being molded by our culture (Roman 12:1-2).  Culturally attuned Christians will have sturdy locks and, perhaps, subscribe to a security service.  Those same Christians will eschew the pervasive suspicion and fear that sees every person hued differently than themselves as a threat.  This doesn’t mean a Christian shouldn’t own a gun but I hear a subtle and disturbing distinction between “I own a gun in case I need to protect my family” and “I own a gun in case I need to kill someone.”  (I’ve heard Christians say both.)

Years ago—long before the gun-rights debates began in earnest—I was eating lunch with a group of fellow seminary students.  George said someone had stolen a lawn chair off his porch; he saw the man take it and run down the street before he could get outside and yell for him to stop.  Frank spoke up to say he would have grabbed his gun and stopped him.  Jerry said taking a life to protect a cheap lawn chair seemed a little extreme.  Frank said it was his property and he had the right to protect it.  Christians will know the difference between honoring property rights and materialism; they also know the value of human life.  Protecting personal property will, for these Christians, stop short of encouraging a property-owner to declare theft a capital crime. 

I’ve heard praise for those cultures where a thief has a hand lopped off for punishment.  A good way to stop theft, it’s claimed. A better way to make sure the thief is less able to do honest work, it seems to me.  The Biblical response to theft isn’t maiming or execution; it’s restitution. 

Adams likely would remind us we live in a broken world, corrupted by sin. He believed slavery was wrong; he believed women should be educated (to an extent); but he also “...stridently campaigned against ‘theatrical entertainments,’ inveighing against the supposedly deleterious effects of horse racing, theater-going, dancing, card playing and salty language. The curbing of such ‘idle amusements’ was necessary, he believed, to restore virtue and to preserve revolutionary gains.” (From Michael Moynihan’s review of “Samuel Adams: A Life” by Ira Stoll at https://nypost.com/2008/11/23/samuel-adams-a-life/) We can only imagine Adams’s response to the Red Sox making the brew bearing his name the team’s official beer.

As governor of Massachusetts, Adams crafted an educational system that required each student to study the Westminster Catechism or some catechism favored by the student’s parents; all would be taught and challenged to adopt a distinctly Christian moral framework. 

As a Baptist, though I might agree with much of the worldview embodied in those catechisms and believe our culture would benefit from embracing basic Christian morality, I cannot endorse a program making public schools a part of the church’s indoctrination program. Coercion, no matter how mild, is not effective evangelism. Many Christians of all denominations would object to schools attempting to fill this role.

Yet, many of those who would never accept Adams’s educational philosophy or his perspective on amusements like plays, dances, and card playing will defend his view of gun-rights as if it were sacrosanct. 

If we can recognize his attitude about horse racing might be outdated, perhaps we should more seriously examine his notions about guns.  Of course, the man who wanted reason rather than feeling to direct our actions might have some surprising things to add to the conversation about gun control. 

I would not put words into his mouth or try to guess what his pen would write.  Instead, I’ll just raise some questions to start us talking.

·                Shouldn’t reasonable gun control include a more widespread use of “red-flag” laws designed to keep guns out of potential suicides (60% of gun deaths in 2016 were suicides)?
·                Shouldn’t reasonable gun control give local authorities greater latitude to commit those showing signs of mental instability? Such laws might have prevented the Parkland shooting.
·                Shouldn’t reasonable gun control laws increase the legal age to purchase a gun?  Perhaps no one under the age of twenty-one who is not an active member of the military should be able to purchase handgun.
·                Shouldn’t reasonable gun control require gun owners who have children under the age of twelve to keep their guns locked up?  Such owners might be allowed to keep one weapon available but out of a child’s reach.



We need to talk about guns rationally.  The NRA won’t.  Those who believe every gun should be melted down won’t.  Most of us are somewhere in between. 

During 2016 and 2017, mass shootings accounted for fewer than 500 gun deaths.   During 2016 some 38,658 people died from gunshots.  Though, almost 99% of the gun deaths that year were not related to mass shootings, these tragic events—such as Las Vegas and Parkland—get us talking.  They should.  There will be no simple answer.

I don’t know what Samuel Adams would say.  Yet, I suspect he would encourage us to ask some pointed questions: Why are our children so angry? Who gives shooters the right to take their anger out on the innocent? Why are women so rarely the perpetrators of these mass shootings? Were our churches occupied with other, less-important matters when some of our children lost their way?

Whatever Sam Adams might say on the matter of gun control, we must look at the circumstances we face and seek to shape a thoughtful, caring, and effective response.

Friday, March 2, 2018

Defeat to Victory


The Alamo, which you, no doubt, remember, became part of Texas and American history on March 6, 1836. About 4 a.m. that Sunday morning, Santa Anna’s troops breached the mission walls, ending a siege lasting almost two weeks.  The Alamo’s defenders killed during siege (sometimes referred to as “the thirteen days to glory”) or, perhaps, executed shortly after included William Travis, James Bowie, David Crockett, and about 200 others—Americans and Mexicans; men from Scotland, England, Ireland (about a dozen), Germany, and Denmark.  Most would “die like a soldier[s] who never [forget] what is due to [their] own honor & that of [their] country,” to borrow Travis’s famous and futile plea for reinforcements. 
In Texas they’re larger-than-life heroes so it’s easy to forget they lost.  But their loss helped Texas win the revolution.  The two weeks Santa Anna spent capturing the Alamo and the two weeks he delayed in San Antonio allowing his wounded and exhausted troops to recover, gave the Texian forces time to prepare for their ultimate victory at San Jacinto six weeks later.
Sometimes we must experience defeat before we can experience victory. 
A humiliating loss at tennis may prompt us to practice our forehand, backhand, and serve until we can win, at least occasionally.
A young Moses experienced defeat when he first attempted to help his people, the Hebrews.  He killed one of the brutal Egyptian taskmasters; then tried to hide his body.  As Ian Thomas suggests, with all that sand around him Moses must have left a toe sticking out.  But that failure led him to allow God to shape him into the liberator he would become.
Like Peter we may experience defeat until we learn victory requires relying on Christ for strength and boldness.
By God’s grace, our defeats may be a prelude to victories.
Almost exactly century before the Alamo’s fall (7 March 1736), John Wesley began his ministry in the budding town of Savannah in what would become Georgia. He went home in defeat: “I went to America to convert the Indians; but, oh, who shall convert me,” the failed missionary wrote.
But that defeat revealed his spiritual poverty and prepared him to finally “trust…Christ alone, for salvation.” He would help initiate one of the most influential movements in modern church history.


[If you regularly read this blog, I should mention I have just corrected an error in "October Madness," a post I wrote last year.  Sorry about any confusion it may have generated.]

Wednesday, February 7, 2018

Do You Believe in Marriage?

Emperor Claudius didn’t believe in marriage; marriage impeded his ambition. Claudius needed men for his army. But Roman law forbade conscripting married men. So Claudius forbade new marriages.
A Roman priest believed in marriage. He continued marrying young couples, often secretly.  His defiance discovered, he was beheaded on 14 February 278. The priest’s name? Valentine
Historians disagree over the details of St. Valentine’s story, but clearly he believed in marriage when influential people held marriage in disdain.
Since 1980 we’ve heard half of new marriages will end in divorce. That statistic is no longer true, and it is widely disputed; in fact, Sarah Jacoby suggests,  “if [the] current trend continues, the vast majority (about two-thirds) of marriages will never divorce.” (http://www.refinery29.com/2017/01/137440/divorce-rate-in-america-statistics. Accessed 3 February 2018.) That’s still a lot of divorces but it’s clear a lot of us believe in marriage, maybe more than in 1980.

If you believe in marriage, how can you make that marriage last?  A tricky question. 
Back in the day (my high school days, at least), any lessons on making marriage last began with a warning about “unrealistic expectations.” I think they were trying to tell us happily ever after wasn’t what we imagined.
After my father died, my mother used to say, “In forty-six years of marriage we never had a cross word.”
One doesn’t call one’s mother a liar but I wonder if her memory might have been a bit blurred. No arguments? Ever?
Doesn’t seem realistic.  I suppose most people hearing her realized she was looking at a past existing only in her dreams.  They forgave her because of her grief. 
Still, I wonder if some young couple heard her and feared for the future of their marriage because they had had such a battle just that morning over the empty toilet paper roll.
I don’t have a formula for a conflict free marriage.  But I will comment on some of the ingredients seemingly associated with successful marriages.  As you will see, some of these factors are more important than others.

Maturity

Under this heading, I am including two factors usually mentioned as characterizing those whose marriages have survived.
Age.  Couples older than 25 when marrying for the first time are less likely to see their marriages end in divorce.  The optimum age for avoiding divorce is 28 to 32, according to one recent study.  Of course, if you married at age nineteen, you don’t need to worry; as with all such statistics, these are generalities.  Still, if you know a twenty-one-year-old who can’t wait to get married (to anyone), you might urge patience.
By the way, the claim that living together before marriage increases the likelihood of divorce is still valid.  A Washington-state based family law firm says it can increase the chances of divorce as much as 40%.  Perhaps living together before marriage betrays the absence of a fundamental element of maturity: the ability to postpone gratification.
Education. For some reason, still not fully explained, those with a college or university education divorce less frequently than those without degrees. 
Wendy Wang, writing for Pew Research, breaks down the figures by gender.  She first explains how college-educated women have an almost 80% chance for their marriages lasting over twenty years, compared to the national average of about 50% and then adds:
 While more-educated women have the highest chances for a long-term marriage, college-educated men also stand out. Roughly two-thirds (65%) of men with a bachelor’s degree could expect that, if they marry, their first marriage will last 20 years or longer, compared with 50% of men with a high school diploma or less. (http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/12/04/education-and-marriage/. Accessed 6 February 2018.)
Wang’s use of the questionable 50% national rate does not diminish the fact the marriages of college-educated people last longer.
Of course, we may assume young men and women who’ve had four years of college will know their needs and goals better than will the high-school sweethearts who marry while the echoes of pomp-and-circumstance are still bouncing around the auditorium.  But it is not as easy to explain why a twenty-five year old with a college degree is more likely to have a stable marriage than a twenty-five year old who doesn’t. One reason Wang suggests concerns financial stability: college graduates are more likely to have secure jobs than less-educated members of the workforce.  Increasingly, however, Wang’s suggestion will carry less weight as becomes clearer a traditional college education is no longer required if a young person wants a well-paying career; jobs in newer technologies, for example, do not always demands a degree.
There are, doubtless, reasons unrelated to preparation for a career that explain why an education should help strengthen marriages.  But this is not a place to explore them.

Location

I love visiting Austin, Texas. It’s a lively, interesting city. Though not as famous for its food as, say, New Orleans, Austin has some great restaurants and you can eat at many of the best without taking a bank loan.  Some of the best BBQ in the nation is available in Austin—I enjoy a place where I can also buy gasoline.  Being the capital of Texas, you can satisfy your steak cravings as well.  Of course, you can get fajitas and tacos everywhere. Looking for simpler meals?  One street has so many independent, non-franchise burger joints it would take two weeks to eat lunch at each of them. 
Even though Austin has a restaurant where servers wear shirts saying, “I didn’t get to the top of the food chain to become a vegetarian,” the city also has many vegetarian and vegan restaurants. Bouldin Creek Café is my favorite—no kidding.
Don’t make assumptions about places on the map.
Still, some surveys link the likelihood of divorce to your location. 
Here are some statistics from a 2013 survey cited by Jacoby, “States have widely varying rates of divorce. Nevada and Maine have the highest rates (around 14%)…. Other states with higher rates include Oklahoma, Florida, Oregon, and Kentucky. On the other end, New York, New Jersey, Utah, California, and North Dakota have some of the lowest rates (between 8.7% and 9.7%).”  That’s right; California has a low divorce rate. 
I’m not sure everything those figures mean. They certainly don’t mean if you live in Oregon, you should start packing to move across the country to New York to save your marriage.  They do suggest living in a “red” state doesn’t protect you from divorce and living in a “blue” state doesn’t mean you are likely to divorce. In fact, George Barna found marriages in red states are more likely to end in divorce than those in blue states.
While such snippets of information might be useful for restarting stalled conversations at a wedding reception, where you live might not be relevant to safeguarding your marriage from divorce.
Perhaps the best location is a place where you have friends and a reliable support system. 

Shared Religious Life

Just how religion helps in making a good marriage is debated.  I found statistics claiming Southern Baptists are slightly more likely to divorce than atheists.  That’s disturbing but the claim may require a little honest tweaking.  And, since I am a former Southern Baptist pastor, I think I have the right to do that tweaking.
First, claiming to be a Southern Baptist does not necessarily imply a deep commitment to the church.  With some sixteen million members nationwide, the Southern Baptist Convention is the largest Protestant group in America.  Yet, on any Sunday only half those members are in any church.  When I came to the first church I served, it was proudly pointed out that the prosperous businessman who lived across the street from the church was a member.  In his forties, married and the father of two children, he had joined the church when he was fifteen. Since the day he joined, he had never again come to a service.   
Southern Baptists spend millions producing some of the finest Sunday school literature.  Southern Baptist pastors spend many hours each week preparing to preach on Sunday morning.  That literature and those sermons will have no impact on those not present to hear the lessons or the sermons.
This points up a second issue. We Southern Baptists have not always been careful in spiritually vetting those coming for membership.  Some studies show the average age of those baptized in our churches has been steadily dropping; some of our churches have even reported baptizing four-year-olds. Phebe Bartlett, converted under Jonathan Edwards’ preaching, is probably the most famous child convert in the annals of American revivalism; her conversion seemed genuine but may have also been exceptional. While I believe we should remain hesitant about declaring who is and isn’t a believer, we need to admit that sometimes those “making a profession of faith” in response to invitations are doing little more than concurring, “This Jesus seems to be a pretty nice guy.”
Though a greater percentage of Southern Baptists may divorce than atheists, religion is not necessarily ineffective in supporting and encouraging healthy marriages.  As Jacoby says, “having a stronger connection to religion tends to keep a marriage more stable.”
In fact, important studies suggest the likelihood of divorce decreases among those who regularly attend church.  The greater the commitment shown to the local church, the greater the security manifested the marriage.
While I’d like to believe my preaching on the nuances of the parousia or the implications of Greek verbs helped keep marriages strong, I suspect it was something else.  A healthy church provides a support system (koinonia) where couples find encouragement and guidance from other, often older, couples who’ve faced and overcome challenges in their marriages.

Children

Having children also seems to be a safeguard against divorce. While “staying together for the kids” is sometimes maligned as a reason to eschew divorce, studies seem to suggest divorce is less likely when a couple has children.
The most doctrinaire Darwinist and the most unrepentant young-earth creationist understand the presence of children in the home says, “Not everything is about you.”
The common wisdom of centuries says a child needs a stable home and two parents, a mom and a dad. This doesn’t mean a single parent can’t raise a child successfully; it does mean an already tough job will be tougher.
Try as they might, moderns sociologists cannot escape this reality. Some are more honest about it than others. 
We might expect groups like Focus on the Family to defend the “traditional family,” but sometimes support comes from unexpected sources.  In 2008, the UK Daily Mail reported on a study made by researchers at Uppsala University in Sweden. The study concluded not only that children need their fathers but also “… found that children who lived with both a mother and father figure had fewer behavioural problems than those who lived with their mother only.” (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-513962/Dads-DO-matter-Why-children-brought-BOTH-parents-happier-successful.html#ixzz56GiEA5q8. Accessed 5 February 2018.)  Both boys and girls fared better if they had a positive relationship with both parents. The duration the study (20 years) is important since it predates the propagandistic furor surrounding the debate over same-sex marriage coloring many recent proclamations about the superfluous role of the father in child-rearing.
Couples staying together for the sake of their children are keeping the future in view. If the mother and father can maintain a fundamentally civil atmosphere in the home and demonstrate the give-and-take necessary to do the job of parenting, they will likely bless the coming generation. Christian couples who might have been considering divorce will inevitably realize their need for God’s help in accomplishing the goal of raising spiritually and emotionally healthy children.
At the same time, they may discover the issues feeding the impulse to divorce will recede and they will genuinely want to stay together.
Before moving on, let me offer two cautionary notes.
First, nothing I have said should imply a troubled couple should have children to forestall divorce.  That’s too risky and too unfair.
Second, several studies suggest couples with children are often unhappier after children arrive in the home.  As I read the remarks of young parents on Facebook, remarks suggesting their children are the brightest and cutest who ever toddled across the floor, those studies seem questionable to say the least.  Still, their findings are continually quoted. 
To be honest, children bring changes, sometimes stressful, changes.  The wife who accuses her husband of being infantile never really has to change his diaper.  That’s not true of the little bundle just home from the hospital.  Toddlerhood, childhood, and adolescence bring new stresses. But with time parents find those stresses diminishing or, perhaps, their skills in handling the stresses increasing.  Consequently, older parents generally can’t imagine ever feeling unhappy about having their children.
Of course, children can sometimes limit both the mother’s and the father’s opportunities for career advancement, though—to be honest—the mother is most often impacted.  But dealing with this disappointment challenges parents to carefully assess their priorities, to determine what is important.
Charles Swindoll has said, “Each day we are making deposits in the memory banks of our children.”  I certainly think that’s true.  It may also be that modeling a good marriage before our children will be the best safeguard against their own marriages ending in divorce.

This Valentine’s Day, as you gush over the candy, the flowers, or the cards, say a good word for marriage.  Let people know you believe in marriage.

Friday, January 19, 2018

What the Civil War Can Teach Us About the Bible

Today is Confederate Heroes Day in Texas; its juxtaposition with Martin Luther King, Jr. Day offends some. In fairness, Heroes Day was inaugurated in 1931, when King was two.  Many southerners once viewed Confederate soldiers not only as courageous patriots but as Christian knights defending a culture endorsed by the Scripture.
Evangelicals, northern and southern, quoted the Bible. But the pro-slavery side could muster more “proof texts” than the abolitionists. In time, evangelical abolitionists recognized we must differentiate behaviors and social structures the Bible prescribes and those the Bible simply describes. God does not necessarily approve the latter; so references to slavery usually regulated rather than condoned the practice.
Taking the Bible seriously involves reading the Bible thoughtfully.
I doubt any southern evangelicals today would insist the Bible endorses slavery.  Many might even question the wisdom of keeping a holiday like Confederate Heroes Day on the calendar.  I lived in Texas for almost two decades and never heard of the holiday.  It should be allowed to slip into the mists of best-forgotten history.
But its lessons for reading the Bible thoughtfully need to be remembered. In interpreting and applying the Bible we must consider the context of the passage and the author’s intent.  
It is unlikely Paul—who belonged to a people who had once been slaves—endorsed slavery.  He may be thought of as writing for the interim; we can imagine him looking ahead to a time when slavery was no more.  Clearly he felt slavery limited human potential.  Thus, he told Christian slaves to take the opportunity to be free should it arise (I Corinthians 7:21). Yet, he recognized an enslaved believer could still experience God’s grace and goodness, even in a less than ideal situation.  
If Paul opposed slavery, why didn’t he say more?  Telling Christian slaves to revolt would have seen thousands slaughtered; commanding Christian slave-owners to release their slaves might have led to resentment. Telling the Christian slave-owner Philemon to treat his former runaway slave Onesimus as as brother laid a foundation for a new attitude that would make Christian endorsement of slavery a contradiction.  This, combined with the declaration of spiritual equality found in Galatians 3:28, should have been enough to make any Christian take up the abolitionist cause.  Yet, southern evangelicals defended slavery, even to the point of laying down their lives.
To understand how this can be requires recognizing the power of cultural pressure.  The South thrived on slavery, slavery allowed slave-owners to imagine themselves morally and intellectually superior; it was hard to trump these factors.  To justify slavery, southern evangelicals used “proof texts” and ignored the implications of the good news brought by the One who came to set men and women free.
Again, had those Christians made a thoughtful difference between what the Bible commends and what the Bible reports (and tries to regulate), there might have been no Civil War; slavery might have never received tacit Christian approval.
Keeping the distinction between prescriptive and descriptive passages can help us in dealing with other matters.  For example, consider what was said to Eve after she and Adam fell.  God predicted there would be hostility between men and women, a constant struggle for the upper hand. Did God intend this for the crown of creation?  No.  Instead, God seems to be predicting what would happen, not what should happen.  As Christians we should strive to live as God intended, showing in our lives the transformation wrought by Christ.


Wednesday, January 3, 2018

For a New Year

Prompted by the two-faced Roman god Janus, for whom January is named, we usually spend awhile looking ahead and looking back as a year begins.
We’ll likely experience a mix of disappointment and satisfaction reviewing 2017; though some may feel overwhelmed with disappointment, few would claim to be completely satisfied.

Perhaps you believe in a God who so overturned the events of a day of death, injustice, and darkness we call that day, “Good Friday.” Because of this, several January’s from now you may be able to look back on some events of 2017 and say, “Now I get it.”